Tag Archives: Geoff Miller

The England selectors and their love of consistency

Oh it’s so bloody ‘ard being a selector, oh what a terrible job, how I lament your horrific job Geoff Miller et al.  Please, someone call Amnesty International.

The various England one-day squads were announced today.  The main two are:

Squad for ODIs v Australia & Champions Trophy: Andrew Strauss (capt), James Anderson, Ravi Bopara, Tim Bresnan, Stuart Broad, Paul Collingwood, Joe Denly, Andrew Flintoff, Eoin Morgan, Matt Prior (wk), Adil Rashid, Owais Shah, Ryan Sidebottom, Graeme Swann, Luke Wright.

Squad for Twenty20 internationals v Australia: Paul Collingwood (capt), James Anderson, Ravi Bopara, Tim Bresnan, Stuart Broad, Joe Denly, Andrew Flintoff, Eoin Morgan, Matt Prior (wk), Adil Rashid, Owais Shah, Ryan Sidebottom, Graeme Swann, Jonathan Trott, Luke Wright.

The selectors go on, and on, and on about consistent selection.  To the point of detriment, if you agree with Mike Atherton, which of course The Leading Edge does.  Clearly though, we at least get consistency at Test level, even if does veer on ridiculous.

Alas, if only it was the same in one-day cricket.  The merry-go-round is utterly stupid, and is only going to make things harder for an England ODI team that are already poor enough.  If The Leading Edge could meet the selectors, these questions concerning their much coveted ‘consistency’ would be posed:

1. Trott is in line to make his test debut on Thursday.  Fair play.  I’ll save the lament for Big Bobby Key for another day.  He’s been selected for the Twenty20 squad.  Fair play, he’s been one of the best players in this years tournament.  One day squad?  Not in it.  Clearly Trott is this horrific modern breed player who can only play Test cricket and Twenty20 cricket.  Mention ODI’s and he’ll (probably (not)) spit in your face in anger.

2. Joe Denly is clearly a class player, who will go on to play for England, probably excelling in the Test game which reflects his success in the first-class game, but is in the one-day squads.  Jonathan Trott is an enforcer, aggressive type player who bullies opposition attacks, with notable succcess in the one-day and twenty20 games: He will probably go onto be a class one-day player for England, but isn’t in the ODI squad.  D’yageddit?

3. Openers – Yes, Joe Denly, all good etc.  But do we really need another ODI opener to try and toss to the side?  I think Strauss and Bopara could be a much plentiful opening pair…if given a go.  They’re not alone, in the last 3 years 17 partnerships have been used, the most “prolific” being that famous food based pairing: Cook and Mustard (in the same time period, the Test team has used 3).  The scored 339 runs in 10 innings at about 5 an over.  Then suddenyl, they were both gone, with no explanation.  Over the last few years, there have been several good opening pairings for England who started well, but were just dropped or moved.  Eg, Bell and Prior against South Africa last summer, and er… Mal Loye and Ed Joyce in Australia 2007?  This is seriously ridiculous, please, just let two openers play, together, for maybe 30 innings, just see what happens.

The speed in which players gets dropped is shocking, there’s clearly no long term strategy – unlike the Test team.  Imagine if after a Test series, Cook just got dropped.  No explanation.  Done nothing wrong, albeit nothing particularly right.  Just gone.  If Denly does get a run at the top order, presumably with Strauss, please give him some time to settle.  Maybe then England can compete with the ODI big boys, finally.

Leave a comment

Filed under The Leading Edge